Right and Wrong vs Reality

This comes at me from multiple directions and I’ve helped people navigate it a few times (not recently😕) but it keeps on popping up: we don’t have a right to medication.

Or medical treatment in general

There is EMTALA and some of the small provisions in the ACA of course

But that’s about emergencies

If you have a chronic illness, no one is obligated to treat you for it

If you have type 1 diabetes, no one has to give you insulin if you can’t pay for. Some programs exist in our country to try to help people get it. But again, if you can’t pay for it yourself no one is required to give it to you.

If you have a bleeding disorder no one is required to give you a plasma based medicine.

In an emergency, sometimes. But only if you’re in the right place with access to the right care

If you need chronic care to live you don’t have a right to get it

Go look up pictures of type 1 diabetics before Banting and insulin

Go look up treatments for hemophiliacs before the 1900’s, when most didn’t make it past the second decade of life

So many don’t seem to understand this

Or understand what it would mean to have a protected right to healthcare

It’s not like the government gives us rights. We don’t have a right to free practice because a document says so. The document is an agreement between the citizens of this country to create institutions that will defend that right for each individual living here.

The government itself is not allowed to infringe upon that right for sure. But if someone toes you down and forces you to pray the government is obligated to intervene.

The government is obligated ensure that no person is enslaved

The government is obligated to ensure all can vote.

We all have those rights

We’ve also created institutions that ensure we can exercise them.

Without those institutions. We wouldn’t be able to with any certainty, just look around the world and you’ll see many examples.

There is no institution that guarantees medications or therapies

There is no equivalent to the courts or military or police or CDC, for health related concerns.

Not that those institutions are perfect

There just isn’t any institution that currently exists aimed at keeping sick people alive.

Right or wrong

Not the question

Right/Wrong vs Reality

Reality; if you’re sick, you have no right to the technologies that will keep you alive.

You can pay for the privilege of using those technologies.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s